Texas Butter recipe Shrimp and Fish Sandwich

Blackbeard's Grilled Seafood Sandwich

Course: Main Course
Cuisine: American
Prep: 10 minutes
Burn Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 25 minutes
Mouths: 1
Calories: 1410 kcal
Author: txbut

Super simple clean cajun sandwich named after Blackbeard because. Pirates didn't use fryers on the ship. I mean, can you imagine the on the job injuries with fryers sloshing hot grease all over the damn deck? Insurance would skyrocket... 

Anyways, a friend asked how I grill fish without it turning into a grilling disaster. Well, I don't really know and disasters happen here too. 

Here's my rules: 

Stay grill side. 

Preheat grill to medium high. 

The grill grates are well seasoned and not stripped to bare metal (ever). 

Indirect heat touch the fish twice, once to flip n once to pull from grill. 

I don't normally coat food with oils. You can

Look for white half way up the fish as an indicator to flip. Big metal spatula helps a lot and the flip is a delicate move like frying an egg. 

If the shrimp are big enough I'll lay each one on grill and by the time I get them all on grill the 1st ones need to be flipped. There are grill baskets for fish and shrimp.

Print 🖨️


  • 1 lb fish fillet, I do Red's when fresh but Swai is my addiction 24/7
  • 6 oz shrimp ='s 6 shrimp jumbo cleaned
  • 4 oz bacon ='s 2 slices
  • 1 oz sour cream
  • 2 tbs Cottonmouth
  • 1 tbs relish sweet, sour, both
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 2 oz bread ='s 1 bun
  • 1 tsp lime squeeze
  • 1 tsp butter
  • 1/2 oz lettuce a leaf or two

The Build

  1. Bake your bacon at 350 for 30 minutes in oven. This is what bottlenecks and takes all the time so precooked would be great.
  2. Get your pit up to medium high on half side and a small pan on stove at medium heat to toast bun.
  3. Coat all sides of the red fish and shrimp with Cottonmouth.
  4. Sprinkle dash of salt all over too. To taste, less is safer.
  5. Put butter in heated pan and drop both sides of bun on top.
  6. Pull buns from heat when browned. Should be about 2 minutes.
  7. Place fish on grill to the side of the heat source.
  8. Start timer for 3 minutes.
  9. Place shrimp on grill.
  10. How's the redfish doing? Ready to flip? Make the call, look for white up the side and or dark grill marks. The timer lets you know you're close.
  11. Do the same for shrimp on whether to flip or not.
  12. Grill marks are not as important as seeing white rise at the side of animal. Half way up it's time to flip. Depending on your heat "power" you may not get any grill marks worth writing home about. It will be fine, no worries 😉
  13. Pull when other side is done and squirt some lime all it/them.
  14. Stack it all up and add whatever makes your best fish sandwich the best!


You will have extra fish and shrimp to make another sammie of just fork it.

➕ Nutrition - About

Hay yall! Don’t be afraid to adjust or substitute ingredients to your taste. None of these recipes came from a written measured recipe. They are made, noted, measured on the fly, then pumped up here when time permits. If you don’t have any Texas Butter I guess we’ll overlook it if you use what’s in your pantry. Be sure to ask how something turned out or you have questions. Expect grammar errors, these are not checked much. Well, in general I can’t spell worth a crap. Thanks – Shawn

Nutrition Facts
Blackbeard's Grilled Seafood Sandwich
Amount Per Serving (355 g)
Calories 1410 Calories from Fat 594
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 66g 102%
Saturated Fat 24g 120%
Cholesterol 755mg 252%
Sodium 4050mg 169%
Potassium 2243mg 64%
Total Carbohydrates 48g 16%
Dietary Fiber 6g 24%
Sugars 4g
Protein 148g 296%
Vitamin A 75%
Vitamin C 8.6%
Calcium 45.3%
Iron 63.7%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Spin-n-Save! 💰
Kindly get back to your previous orientation view... your wheel is rolling there...
Close this crap

Your coupon has been sent to your email. You can also use the coupon now if you have product in cart. 👍

 We want you to become an Amigo! 

Why? Our price is the best price, but looky HERE. 🔫

🍅 Our products are so fresh there is no inventory. 🍅

Average delivered in 4 - 5 days!.

  • Just one spin, it's hard to lose!
  • You can claim your coupon within 15 days
  • We don't honor any monkey business.
Your Coupon code is "{coupon}". Insert code in coupon hole on cart or checkout page then click update.X